Chapter 6 - ETHAN

Our son was born at 4:38 that afternoon.
For twelve hours, my family had been collapsing around me.
Then Ethan Carter entered the world screaming.
And suddenly nothing else existed.
Seven pounds, two ounces.
Dark hair.
Tiny clenched fists.
Angry at the universe.
Perfect.
When the nurse placed him against Annaâs chest, she sobbed.
I kissed both of them.
âIâm sorry.â
Anna looked up.
âFor what?â
âFor not seeing you.â
Her face softened.
âYou see me now.â
It should have been the happiest moment of my life.
It almost was.
Then a hospital security officer entered.
âMr. Carter?â
I stood.
âYes?â
âA woman claiming to be the babyâs grandmother is downstairs demanding access.â
Anna went rigid.
âNo.â
I answered before the officer could ask.
âShe is not allowed anywhere near my wife or child.â
He nodded.
âWeâve already flagged the room.â
My mother called twenty-seven times that evening.
She left four voicemails.
The first was angry.
The second was crying.
The third blamed Anna.
The fourth terrified me.
âNathan, youâre making decisions you donât understand. There are things your father did that you know nothing about. If you keep digging, youâre going to destroy his memory too.â
I saved every message.
The next morning, Rebecca came to the hospital with the ledger.
Samuel came with her.
He looked exactly like I imagined someone who had spent decades auditing dishonest people would look.
Thin.
Gray.
Eyes that missed nothing.
He stood beside Ethanâs bassinet for a long moment.
âDaniel wouldâve liked him.â
My throat tightened.
Samuel opened the ledger.
My fatherâs handwriting covered page after page.
Dates.
Amounts.
Initials.
Questions.
Near the end, the entries became frantic.
Samuel pointed to the payments connected to Dr. Klein.
âEvelyn wasnât paying him directly.â
âThen what is this?â
âThese are checks from one of the shell vendors.â
âWhat does that mean?â
âShe controlled the vendor.â
âSo indirectly, she paid him.â
âYes.â
âFor what?â
âThatâs what Daniel wanted to know.â
Rebecca had searched public records.
Dr. Klein retired six years earlier.
He had also been investigated by the state medical board.
Not for my father.
For improper prescribing.
I leaned back.
Anna immediately saw where my mind had gone.
âNathan.â
âI know.â
âNo, you donât.â
She reached across the bed.
âYouâre about to convince yourself your mother killed your father.â
I said nothing.
âAnd maybe she did something terrible,â Anna continued. âBut you need evidence. Not rage.â
She was right.
After everything my mother had done to her, Anna was still the calmest person in the room.
Samuel nodded.
âYour father taught you well when he wasnât being stubborn.â
A knock came at the door.
Detective Morales entered.
He had news.
The tablets from Annaâs robe matched medication prescribed to my mother several months earlier.
My mother claimed Anna stole them.
Anna laughed for the first time since labor.
It wasnât humor.
âShe said I stole her pills?â
Morales nodded.
âShe says youâve been unstable throughout the pregnancy.â
I felt Anna shrink.
I stood.
Morales raised a hand.
âIâm not saying we believe her.â
âSheâs doing exactly what she threatened.â
âI know.â
He had reviewed Annaâs recorded statement.
There was something else.
âYour mother filed a report this morning.â
âFor what?â
âShe claims several pieces of jewelry are missing from your home.â
I stared at him.
âLet me guess.â
âShe believes your wife took them.â
Anna shut her eyes.
The trap was unfolding exactly as promised.
But my mother had made one mistake.
She was moving too fast.
Morales asked,
âDo you have interior cameras?â
âWe did.â
âFootage?â
âThe system stores online.â
I checked.
The cameras had been disconnected yesterday.
But the previous thirty days remained.
I gave Morales access.
He left.
Samuel looked at me.
âSheâs trying to control the story.â
âShe always has.â
âThen stop reacting to her version.â
âHow?â
âFind the version sheâs afraid of.â
That afternoon, I watched security footage.
Hours of nothing.
Hallways.
Doors.
My mother carrying laundry.
Anna moving through the house.
Then I found something.
Three nights earlier.
2:14 a.m.
My mother walked from her bedroom toward Annaâs purse.
She looked down the hallway.
Reached inside.
Removed something.
Then placed something else inside.
I zoomed in.
Jewelry.
A bracelet.
The same gold bracelet my mother had reported stolen.
I sent the video to Detective Morales.
Anna watched from the bed.
âShe planted it.â
âYes.â
Her eyes filled.
âShe really meant it.â
âWhat?â
âWhen she said she could make you believe I was a thief.â
I took her hand.
âShe underestimated one thing.â
âWhat?â
âYou.â
Anna frowned.
âShe spent months convincing you that you were powerless.â
I looked at Ethan sleeping beside us.
âShe was wrong.â
My phone buzzed.
A message from Rebecca.
You need to see this.
Attached was a photograph.
It showed my father.
My mother.
And Dr. Klein.
Taken at a restaurant ten years earlier.
The date was written on the back.
But that wasnât what Rebecca wanted me to notice.
Behind them, reflected in the restaurant mirror, was another man.
Samuel.
I looked across the hospital room.
At him.
He stared at the photograph.
His face changed.
âSamuel?â
He didnât answer.
âWho is that man beside you?â
He sat down slowly.
May you like
Then said,
âI was hoping youâd never have to ask me that.â