Chapter 12 - MY FATHERâS VOICE

Finding a cassette player in 2026 was harder than expected.
The police lab had one.
Morales allowed us to hear a digitized copy after investigators reviewed it.
My fatherâs voice filled the small interview room.
I hadnât heard it in years.
Not really.
Old birthday videos were different.
This was Daniel speaking privately.
Afraid.
Aware he might not be alive when his children heard him.
âNathan. Rebecca. If this reaches you, Iâm sorry.â
Rebecca grabbed my hand.
Dad continued.
âI should have left years ago.â
My throat closed.
âI told myself I stayed because of you.â
A pause.
âThat was partly true.â
Another breath.
âBut cowardice can wear the costume of sacrifice.â
Anna squeezed my shoulder.
Dad described discovering Evelynâs theft.
Then Thomas.
Thomas had threatened to report everything.
Victor visited him.
Days later, Thomas vanished.
Dad confronted Evelyn.
âShe told me Thomas would never interfere again.â
My sister cried silently.
Dad said he went to police once.
But without proof, with Evelyn denying everything and Thomas officially considered missing, nothing happened.
Then my mother threatened him.
Not physically.
With us.
âShe told me she would tell the court I was violent.â
Dadâs voice broke.
âShe said she would make sure I never saw my children again.â
I shut my eyes.
My mother had used the same strategy on Anna.
Different generation.
Same weapon.
Dad stayed.
Gathered evidence.
Moved money where Evelyn could not reach it.
Then he discovered the payments to Dr. Klein.
âI donât know what she asked him to do.â
Dadâs breathing sounded uneven.
âBut I no longer trust the medications in this house.â
Rebecca covered her mouth.
The recording ended after forty-three minutes.
No confession.
No proof of murder.
But enough to reopen my fatherâs death investigation.
His remains had been cremated.
No exhumation possible.
Medical records became critical.
Kleinâs altered chart mattered.
Then Victor Hale resurfaced.
He was arrested during a traffic stop two states away.
Morales called me at midnight.
Victor had outstanding warrants unrelated to our family.
Police questioned him.
For nearly eleven hours, he denied everything.
Then they showed him the photograph.
The ledger.
Thomasâs recovered remains.
The tape.
Victor asked for a lawyer.
Two days later, his attorney approached prosecutors.
He wanted a deal.
In exchange, Victor would explain what happened to Thomas Reed.
Annaâs mother sat in our living room when Morales told us.
Her face became expressionless.
âWhat happened to my father?â
Morales could not disclose every detail yet.
But Victor claimed he confronted Thomas on Evelynâs instructions.
The goal was intimidation.
According to Victor, Thomas fought back.
Victor struck him.
Thomas fell.
He died from the injury.
Victor panicked.
Called Evelyn.
Together, according to his statement, they concealed the body on the Carter property.
Annaâs mother stood and walked outside.
Anna followed.
I watched through the window as they held each other.
Sixteen years.
A daughter believed her father left willingly.
A wife buried anger.
A granddaughter married into the family linked to his death.
All because two people decided a truth was too dangerous to survive.
Victor also claimed my mother paid him for years afterward.
Blackmail disguised as consulting.
That explained missing money after my fatherâs death.
But what about Daniel?
Victor denied touching him.
âKlein,â Rebecca said.
Morales nodded.
That remained the question.
Then Victor gave prosecutors something unexpected.
Evelyn had contacted him three months earlier.
Shortly after she discovered Anna in Danielâs office.
She wanted him to do something.
Not kill Anna.
Not hurt me.
Something subtler.
She asked Victor to find someone willing to testify that Anna had been seen buying illegal drugs.
My fists clenched.
âShe wanted to make Anna look like an addict.â
Morales nodded.
âShe wanted custody leverage.â
Ethan was asleep upstairs.
I suddenly understood.
My mother wasnât only trying to remove Anna.
She wanted my son.
A new person to control.
A replacement family after losing control of me.
Rebecca whispered,
âShe would have raised him to hate Anna.â
I looked at the staircase.
âNo.â
That word carried more certainty than anything I had ever said.
âShe will never touch my son.â
The next morning, Evelyn Carter was arrested again.
This time the charges were no longer about a kitchen.
They involved Thomas Reed.
Financial crimes.
Conspiracy allegations.
Witness tampering.
Her attorney announced she would fight everything.
Then my mother requested one thing.
To speak to me.
I refused.
She requested again.
I refused again.
The third request came through her lawyer with a message.
Ask Nathan if he wants to know why his father really died.
I agreed to hear her.
Not privately.
Recorded.
With attorneys.
She entered the room in jail clothing.
Sat across the glass.
Picked up the phone.
For several seconds she simply looked at me.
Then she said,
âYour father killed himself.â
May you like
I stared at her.
And she smiled.